TL;DR
- On 12 November the Permanent Deputation of Spain's Congress kept the national housing decree in force by 35 votes to 34 and threw out a second decree on automatic lease renewals (BOE, Euronews).
- The rules are not new: Royal Decree-law 29/2026 has applied since 8 October (RTVC). The vote carries them into the 29 November election, and the Popular Party says it will repeal the government's housing measures if it takes power (AP).
- In Germany, a legal opinion commissioned by Die Linke says the federal government's planned law to curb the socialisation of Berlin flats is unconstitutional (tagesschau). The Berlin exploratory paper of Die Linke, the Greens and the SPD caps compensation at €16bn, provided fiscal sustainability is ensured, against a market value FAZ puts at about €30bn (FAZ).
In one week, Spain's housing rules were tied to an election and Germany's to a constitutional dispute. In Spain, a one-vote margin kept national rules on rents, evictions and discounted purchases in force, about two weeks before an election that could end them. In Germany, the fight over Berlin's flats turned constitutional before any federal law exists. For residential investors, the rules hold today and face a dated test.
What did Spain's parliament decide?
With the Cortes dissolved for the snap election, the vote fell to the Permanent Deputation, the 69-member body that keeps parliament working during a dissolution (Euronews). On Thursday 12 November it convalidated Royal Decree-law 29/2026 by 35 votes to 34, with the single vote of the Basque Nationalist Party (PNV) deciding the outcome (Law&Trends). The resolution was published in the Official State Gazette the next day (BOE).
The same session repealed Royal Decree-law 28/2026 (BOE), which gathered 34 votes (AP). It would have renewed leases for a further five years after the initial term, seven where the landlord is a company, with 12 months' rent in compensation if the landlord ended the contract (Law&Trends). The PNV backed the first decree but voted against renewal, arguing it would shrink rental supply (Euronews).
What stays in force for landlords and buyers?
For annual updates due before 31 December 2027, a rent already above the ceiling of the reference price index cannot rise at all (BOE). Otherwise the parties may agree the increase, and absent an agreement it cannot exceed 2% (BOE).
The heavier provisions for institutional owners run longer. A regime suspending evictions of vulnerable households without alternative housing runs until 31 December 2030, and large holders, along with firms that buy property or non-performing loan portfolios below appraised value, are limited until the same date in buying homes for less than 70% of appraised market value (BOE). A large holder owns more than ten homes, or five in a stressed market zone (RTVC). Socimis, Spain's listed property companies, face a 25% special levy on undistributed profit from residential letting (BOE).
| Rule in Royal Decree-law 29/2026 | Who it reaches | Runs to |
|---|---|---|
| No increase where rent already exceeds the reference index ceiling; otherwise as agreed, at most 2% absent agreement | Residential landlords | 31 December 2027 |
| Suspension regime for evictions of vulnerable households | Landlords of vulnerable tenants | 31 December 2030 |
| Purchases below 70% of appraised market value limited | Large holders and buyers of property or non-performing loan portfolios below appraised value | 31 December 2030 |
| 25% special levy on undistributed residential rental profit | Socimis | Amends the Socimi law (article 9) |
Source: BOE, Royal Decree-law 29/2026, 7 October 2026; large-holder definition from RTVC, 12 November 2026.
Why does the 29 November election matter?
The Popular Party, which polls show could take power, says it will repeal the left-wing government's housing measures (AP). Vox has announced an appeal against the use of the Permanent Deputation to pass a text the full chamber had rejected (Law&Trends).
What is Germany's federal government planning?
A law making it far harder for a state to socialise large portfolios. The federal government has set out key points for the planned investment protection law (Investitionsschutzgesetz). Under them, socialisation would be allowed only as a "last option", once no other measure could solve the problem, with compensation at full market value paid in money (tagesschau). The federal government is still split between 80% and 100% of market value (FAZ).
The target is Berlin. No government led by Die Linke exists there yet (tagesschau), but in exploratory talks Die Linke, the Greens and the SPD agreed to socialise about 160,000 flats of large property companies if they form a government (Handelsblatt/dpa). FAZ puts the figure at about 150,000 (FAZ).
What does the legal opinion say?
That the federal government lacks the legislative competence for such a law (Handelsblatt/dpa). The opinion, by a law professor and two lawyers, was commissioned by Die Linke (tagesschau) and released on 16 November (Die Linke). It argues that the Federal Constitutional Court does not accept federal laws whose only aim is to stop a state from legislating, and Die Linke has said it would sue in Karlsruhe if the law is passed (tagesschau).
How big is the gap in Berlin?
About €14bn, the difference between two figures: the exploratory paper caps compensation at €16bn, provided fiscal sustainability is ensured, while FAZ reports a market value for the affected stock estimated at about €30bn (FAZ). Vonovia's 130,000 Berlin flats alone are valued at more than €20bn (FAZ). The three parties plan a socialisation law by mid-2028 and, a year later, the transfer of flats held by private owners with more than 10,000 units into a public-law institution (FAZ).
Berlin socialisation: the compensation cap against the estimated market value (€bn)
Two housing fights in one week
- 2 October 2026Spain's Congress rejects the first decrees
The full chamber votes down both housing decrees; the government approves them again with small changes.
- 8 October 2026Royal Decree-law 29/2026 applies
The rent, eviction and purchase rules take effect.
- 12 November 2026One vote keeps the decree
The Permanent Deputation convalidates it by 35 to 34 and repeals the lease renewal decree.
- 16 November 2026Berlin opinion published
A legal opinion commissioned by Die Linke calls the planned federal law unconstitutional.
- 29 November 2026Spain votes
The Popular Party says it will repeal the housing measures if it takes power.
- Mid-2028Berlin's planned law
The three parties aim to present a socialisation law, with the transfer of flats a year later.
Why it matters
Our view: Spain's rules for rental income, the 2% ceiling on rent updates absent agreement, to the end of 2027 and the 25% levy on Socimis' undistributed residential profit, now run into the 29 November election. If the Popular Party takes power and repeals the housing measures, then the limits on evictions and on purchases below 70% of value would go before their 2030 dates. If the government stays in power, then landlords plan with a rent rule to 2027 and purchase limits to 2030.
In Berlin the gap is a number: a conditional €16bn cap against an estimated €30bn market value. If the federal law arrives with compensation at full market value, then the cap would not cover the stock at its estimated value, and the dispute moves to Karlsruhe. If the law fails on competence, as the opinion argues, then the cap becomes the figure owners face.




